Skip to content
Close menu
Shop Now
Sponge Candy
Thanksgiving Treats
Holiday Gifts
Factory Tour
Best Sellers
BuffaLOVE
Gift Sets
Fudge
Popcorn
Truffles & Assortments
Chocolate Candy Bars
Clusters, Bark & Nuts
Caramels & Crunch
Wedding Favors
Sponge Candy
Store Locations
Cheektowaga
East Aurora
Hamburg
Tonawanda
Factory Store and HQ
Fundraising
Corporate Gift
More Info
What is Sponge Candy?
About us
Customer Service
FAQ
Loyalty Rewards Program
Text Message Coupons
Shipping Info
Blog Posts
Log in
Instagram
Facebook
YouTube
Twitter
Pinterest
Cart
Close cart
Order note
Your cart is currently empty.
Shop Now
Sponge Candy
Thanksgiving Treats
Holiday Gifts
Factory Tour
Best Sellers
BuffaLOVE
Gift Sets
Fudge
Popcorn
Truffles & Assortments
Chocolate Candy Bars
Clusters, Bark & Nuts
Caramels & Crunch
Wedding Favors
Sponge Candy
Store Locations
Cheektowaga
East Aurora
Hamburg
Tonawanda
Factory Store and HQ
Fundraising
Corporate Gift
More Info
What is Sponge Candy?
About us
Customer Service
FAQ
Loyalty Rewards Program
Text Message Coupons
Shipping Info
Blog Posts
Log in
Search
Site navigation
Cart
Search
"Close (esc)"
Search
"Close (esc)"
Filter
Close menu
Availability
In stock
(136)
Out of stock
(5)
Types of Chocolate
Almonds
(1)
Bark
(1)
Buffalo
(1)
Candy
(2)
Caramel
(11)
Dark Chocolate
(20)
Dark Mint Chocolate
(1)
Gift Sets
(6)
Milk and Dark Chocolate
(27)
Milk Chocolate
(47)
nut
(1)
Nuts
(7)
Orange Chocolate
(5)
Oreo Cookie
(1)
peanut
(1)
Peanut Butter
(1)
Peanut Butter Filled Milk Chocolate
(1)
Popcorn
(2)
Toffee
(1)
White Chocolate
(2)
All Products
Filter
Sort
Sort
Featured
Best selling
Alphabetically, A-Z
Alphabetically, Z-A
Price, low to high
Price, high to low
Date, old to new
Date, new to old
Sponge Candy
Thanksgiving Treats
Holiday Gifts
Factory Tour
Best Sellers
BuffaLOVE
Gift Sets
Fudge
Popcorn
Truffles & Assortments
Chocolate Candy Bars
Clusters, Bark & Nuts
Caramels & Crunch
Wedding Favors
Quick view
Sponge Candy 1 lb.
$ 29.99
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Sponge Candy 3 Piece
$ 3.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Mini Buffalos
$ 14.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Cold Pack Guarantee
$ 3.00
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Sponge Candy Bar
$ 2.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Holiday Minikins 8 oz.
$ 14.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Sponge Candy in Milk & Dark Chocolate
$ 25.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Peanut Clusters
$ 17.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Sea Salt Caramels
$ 18.75
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Pecan Caramel Cluster
$ 18.75
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Double Dipped Sponge Candy
$ 13.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Coconut Clusters
$ 17.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Sponge Candy with a Holiday Lid
$ 29.99
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Buffaloreos
$ 18.75
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Non Pareils
$ 13.75
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Mini Roses
$ 14.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Premium Milk Chocolate Candy Bar with Peanut Butter
$ 2.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Mini Pretzels - Milk Chocolate 8 oz.
$ 14.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Santa Sucker 1 oz.
$ 2.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Almond Butter Crunch
$ 18.75
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Truffle Assortment
$ 21.75
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Sweet Taste Of Buffalo Bar - Orange Chocolate
$ 2.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Premium Milk Chocolate Candy Bar with Caramel
$ 2.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Truffalo Candy Bar
$ 2.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Rose Sucker 1 oz.
$ 2.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Gold Coins
$ 1.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Premium Milk Chocolate Candy Bar with Crisped Rice
$ 2.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Sweet Taste Of Buffalo Bar - Milk Chocolate
$ 2.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Peanut Butter Truffles
$ 18.75
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Truffaloes
$ 18.75
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Premium Milk Chocolate Candy Bar with Roasted Almonds
$ 2.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Mini Pumpkins
$ 14.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Raisin Clusters
$ 17.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Satellite Wafers 1.5 oz.
$ 3.75
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Chicken Wing Set 2 oz.
$ 3.98
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Gummi Butterflies 8 oz.
$ 3.75
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Buffaloreo 2 Piece
$ 3.75
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Truffalo Bar And 3 Piece Sponge Candy Gift
$ 5.99
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Buffalo Sucker 1 oz.
$ 2.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Candy Lego Building Blocks 4 oz.
$ 2.75
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Mini Turkeys
$ 14.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Peanut Butter Truffle 3 Piece
$ 3.75
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Foiled Chocolate Bells 8 oz.
$ 12.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Almond Butter Crunch 3 Piece
$ 3.75
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Happy Birthday Candy Bar
$ 2.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Sweet Taste Of Buffalo Bar - Dark Chocolate
$ 2.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Charlie's Favorites
$ 18.75
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Merry Christmas Candy Bar
$ 2.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Raspberry Filled Hard Candies 8 oz.
$ 2.99
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Sea Salt Caramel 3 Piece
$ 3.75
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Flat Santa 1.5 oz.
$ 3.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
White Chocolate Melty Mints
$ 4.99
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Complete Assortment Milk and Dark
$ 33.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Decadent Delight 14 oz.
$ 19.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Holiday Cinnamon Pretzels 8 oz.
$ 14.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Santa Plaque 1 oz.
$ 2.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Junior's Mini Footballs 8 oz.
$ 14.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Buffalo Nickel 1 oz.
$ 2.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Buffalo Cookie Cutter 2 oz.
$ 5.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Orange Slices 8 oz.
$ 14.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Pizza & Wings
$ 15.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Snowflake 1.5 oz.
$ 3.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Espresso Beans 8 oz.
$ 7.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Foiled Stars
$ 3.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Gourmet Chocolate & Candy Cane Laced Popcorn
$ 11.99
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Snowman Sucker 1 oz.
$ 2.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Buffalo 716
$ 2.75
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Turkey Sucker 1 oz.
$ 2.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Christmas Spice Drops 8 oz.
$ 2.99
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Cat Sucker 1 oz.
$ 2.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Christmas Tree Sucker 2 oz.
$ 4.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Rock Candy 3 Pack
$ 3.50
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Bridge Mix 8 oz.
$ 7.25
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Regular Assortment 1 lb.
$ 33.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Foiled Santas
$ 12.49
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Buffalo Gift Bag
$ 11.75
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Dark Chocolate Cherry and Almond Bark 7 oz.
$ 15.75
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Platinum Assortment
$ 36.75
"Close (esc)"
Quick view
Santa Sucker 2 oz.
$ 4.25
"Close (esc)"
1
2
Next
"Close (esc)"
All Products