Filter

    All Products

    Quick view
    Sponge Candy 1 lb.
    Sponge Candy 1 lb.
    Sponge Candy 1 lb.
    $ 29.99
    Quick view
    Sponge Candy 3 Piece
    Sponge Candy 1 lb.
    Sponge Candy 3 Piece
    $ 3.49
    Quick view
    Mini Buffalos
    Mini Buffalos
    Mini Buffalos
    $ 14.25
    Quick view
    Cold Pack Guarantee
    Cold Pack Guarantee
    $ 3.00
    Quick view
    Sponge Candy Bar
    Sponge Candy Bar
    $ 2.49
    Quick view
    Sponge Candy in Milk & Dark Chocolate
    Sponge Candy in Milk & Dark Chocolate
    $ 25.49
    Quick view
    Peanut Clusters
    Peanut Clusters
    Peanut Clusters
    $ 17.25
    Quick view
    Sea Salt Caramels
    Sea Salt Caramels
    Sea Salt Caramels
    $ 18.75
    Quick view
    Pecan Caramel Cluster
    Pecan Caramel Cluster
    Pecan Caramel Cluster
    $ 18.75
    Quick view
    Double Dipped Sponge Candy
    Double Dipped Sponge Candy
    Double Dipped Sponge Candy
    $ 13.25
    Quick view
    Coconut Clusters
    Coconut Clusters
    Coconut Clusters
    $ 17.25
    Quick view
    Buffaloreos
    Buffaloreo 2 Piece
    Buffaloreos
    $ 18.75
    Quick view
    Non Pareils
    Non Pareils
    Non Pareils
    $ 13.75
    Quick view
    Mini Roses
    Mini Roses
    Mini Roses
    $ 14.25
    Quick view
    Premium Milk Chocolate Candy Bar with Peanut Butter
    Premium Milk Chocolate Candy Bar with Peanut Butter
    $ 2.49
    Quick view
    Heart Sucker 1 oz.
    $ 2.25
    Quick view
    Mini Pretzels - Milk Chocolate 8 oz.
    Mini Pretzels - Milk Chocolate 8 oz.
    Mini Pretzels - Milk Chocolate 8 oz.
    $ 14.25
    Quick view
    Almond Butter Crunch
    Almond Butter Crunch
    Almond Butter Crunch
    $ 18.75
    Quick view
    Puffy Hearts
    $ 14.25
    Quick view
    Truffle Assortment
    Truffle Assortment
    $ 21.75
    Quick view
    Sweet Taste Of Buffalo Bar - Orange Chocolate
    Sweet Taste Of Buffalo Bar - Orange Chocolate
    $ 2.49
    Quick view
    Premium Milk Chocolate Candy Bar with Caramel
    Premium Milk Chocolate Candy Bar with Caramel
    $ 2.49
    Quick view
    Truffalo Candy Bar
    Truffalo Candy Bar
    $ 2.49
    Quick view
    Gold Coins
    Gold Coins
    $ 1.49
    Quick view
    Premium Milk Chocolate Candy Bar with Crisped Rice
    Premium Milk Chocolate Candy Bar with Crisped Rice
    $ 2.49
    Quick view
    Sweet Taste Of Buffalo Bar - Milk Chocolate
    Sweet Taste Of Buffalo Bar - Milk Chocolate
    $ 2.49
    Sold Out
    Quick view
    Peanut Butter Truffles
    Peanut Butter Truffles
    Peanut Butter Truffles
    $ 18.75
    Quick view
    Truffaloes
    Truffaloes
    $ 18.75
    Quick view
    Premium Milk Chocolate Candy Bar with Roasted Almonds
    Premium Milk Chocolate Candy Bar with Roasted Almonds
    $ 2.49
    Quick view
    5 Piece Truffle Sampler
    5 Piece Truffle Sampler
    $ 7.49
    Quick view
    Raisin Clusters
    Raisin Clusters
    Raisin Clusters
    $ 17.25
    Quick view
    Chicken Wing Set 2 oz.
    Chicken Wing Set 2 oz.
    Chicken Wing Set 2 oz.
    $ 3.98
    Quick view
    Truffalo Bar And 3 Piece Sponge Candy Gift
    Truffalo Bar And 3 Piece Sponge Candy Gift
    $ 5.99
    Quick view
    Buffalo Sucker 1 oz. - Orange Chocolate
    Buffalo Sucker 1 oz.
    $ 2.25
    Quick view
    Candy Lego Building Blocks 4 oz.
    Candy Lego Building Blocks 4 oz.
    $ 2.75
    Quick view
    Foiled Hearts 5 Piece
    $ 3.25
    Quick view
    Foiled Hearts 8 oz.
    Foiled Hearts 8 oz.
    $ 12.99
    Quick view
    Heart 7 oz.
    Heart 7 oz.
    $ 14.25
    Quick view
    Almond Butter Crunch 3 Piece
    Almond Butter Crunch 3 Piece
    Almond Butter Crunch 3 Piece
    $ 3.75
    Quick view
    Happy Birthday Candy Bar
    Happy Birthday Candy Bar
    $ 2.49
    Quick view
    Lace Heart 2.5 oz.
    Lace Heart 2.5 oz.
    $ 5.25
    Quick view
    Sweet Taste Of Buffalo Bar - Dark Chocolate
    Sweet Taste Of Buffalo Bar - Dark Chocolate
    $ 2.49
    Quick view
    Charlie's Favorites
    Charlie's Favorites
    Charlie's Favorites
    $ 18.75
    Quick view
    Sea Salt Caramel 3 Piece
    Sea Salt Caramel 3 Piece
    Sea Salt Caramel 3 Piece
    $ 3.75
    Quick view
    Complete Assortment Milk and Dark
    Complete Assortment Milk and Dark
    $ 33.49
    Quick view
    Decadent Delight 14 oz.
    Decadent Delight 14 oz.
    $ 19.49
    Quick view
    Peanut Butter Mini Footballs 8 oz.
    Junior's Mini Footballs 8 oz.
    $ 14.25
    Quick view
    Buffalo Nickel 1 oz.
    Buffalo Nickel 1 oz.
    $ 2.25
    Quick view
    Buffalo Cookie Cutter 2 oz.
    Buffalo Cookie Cutter 2 oz.
    $ 5.49
    Quick view
    Orange Slices 8 oz.
    Orange Slices 8 oz.
    $ 14.25
    Quick view
    Pizza & Wings
    Pizza & Wings
    $ 15.49
    Quick view
    Espresso Beans 8 oz.
    $ 7.49
    Quick view
    Foiled Stars
    Foiled Stars
    $ 3.25
    Quick view
    Buffalo 716
    Buffalo 716
    $ 2.75
    Quick view
    Happy Valentine's Candy Bar
    Happy Valentine's Candy Bar
    $ 2.49
    Quick view
    Cat Sucker 1 oz.
    $ 2.25
    Quick view
    Rock Candy 3 Pack
    Rock Candy 3 Pack
    $ 3.50
    Quick view
    Bridge Mix 8 oz.
    $ 7.25
    Quick view
    Sponge Candy with a Valentine Lid
    $ 29.99